Perception & Expert Biases: Analyzing Testimony & Critiquing Opinions
Join Suzy Smyth, Ph.D., P.E., CFI, CVFI, and Christy Cloninger, Ph.D. for this COMPLIMENTARY webinar, as they discuss how biases affect witness testimony and expert investigations with a focus on critiquing expert methodology using the concepts of expectation and confirmation bias.
Witness testimony may conflict with physical evidence, other witnesses, and past testimony. We will discuss the science of witness perception and memory as well as present a framework for systematically addressing contradictions. Experts may also
be subject to biases affecting their investigative methodologies. We will discuss expectation and confirmation biases, their appearance in standards (such as NFPA 921), and their use in critiquing expert opinions.
|Christy Cloninger, Ph.D. is Senior Scientist, Human Factors, with Exponent in Chicago. Dr. Cloninger specializes in the study of visual and auditory sensation and perception. She has a background in cognitive and behavioral
neuroscience investigating human motor behavior, motion processing and sensory perception using eye-tracking, behavioral measurements, and computational methods. She currently applies her expertise to investigate human factors in transportation
accidents, warning compliance, as well as slips, trips and falls.
Prior to joining Exponent, Dr. Cloninger completed her graduate studies at the University of Rochester, where she studied sensory neuroscience. Her work there examined
auditory motion processing in humans, using eye and head movement tracking as behavioral outputs of auditory perception. She has extensive experience in human subject research, experimental design, and data analysis, including teaching
and communicating complex scientific topics to a wide variety of audiences.
||Suzanne Smyth, Ph.D., P.E., CFI, CVFI is Managing Engineer, Thermal Sciences, with Exponent in Chicago. Dr. Smyth specializes in the investigation and prevention of fires and explosions in industrial, commercial, and residential
settings. Dr. Smyth has conducted scientific fire and explosion cause and origin analyses involving heavy machinery, consumer appliances, on and off highway vehicles, commercial kitchen equipment, and industrial machinery. She has investigated
incidents in the agricultural, transportation, construction, milling, mining, and other chemical and food processing industries. Her mechanical engineering background includes an emphasis on heat transfer and fluid mechanics with experience
in these fields both experimentally and relative to numerical simulation.
Dr. Smyth has experience with materials flammability testing, forced failure testing, gaseous emission sampling and analysis, laser diagnostics, and theoretical
analyses involving heat transfer and fluid mechanics. She has experience with computational fluid mechanics (CFD) software including PHAST, FLUENT, and Fire Dynamics Simulator (FDS).
Prior to joining Exponent, Dr. Smyth spent two
years as an engineering consultant investigating fires, explosions, and other fluid and thermal related projects. As a graduate student, her research in the Combustion Physics Laboratory involved the study of small-scale catalytically
reacting flows of methane and propane. Dr. Smyth has also served as a Teaching Assistant for undergraduate laboratory courses in heat transfer and fluid dynamics. Additionally, she has experience in the production and testing of biodiesel.
Continuing Legal Education Credit
Credit has been approved with the MCLE Board of the Supreme Court of Illinois for 1.0 General CLE credit.
Our sincere thanks to Exponent for their sponsorship of this event!